Simply Chic Simply Chic Blog Home

'African Queen' editorial uses white model

French fashion magazine features white teen model painted in blackface.

By Charyn Pfeuffer - MSN Living Editor Feb 26, 2013 9:01PM

Photo: Numéro magazineThe fashion world has been known to push the boundaries of what’s socially acceptable and without a doubt, stir controversy.

In the March 2013 issue of Numéro magazine, 16-year-old white model Ondria Hardin appears drenched in a very deep bronze for a fashion spread called "African Queen,” reports Jezebel.com.

More from Simply Chic: Are Thin Models Going Out of Style?

Hello! This would have been the perfect opportunity to hire a black model, as there are fewer job opportunities for non-white models. Eighty-two percent of the models at New York Fashion Week this season were white, cites Jezebel.

More than 150 people have commented on author Laura Beck’s article, including this one from “fashionlady”

“Can I just say as a young black model (I'm a girl) having worked my ass for the past 3 years, this hurts my soul. I'm happy for Ondria as a person but the amount of times I have been told ‘oh sorry we already have a black girl that looks like you’ or ‘most of our clients dont hire black girls, sorry’ and then I see THIS, it pisses me off! There are so many beauitful black models out there working TWICE as hard for barely half the recognition and the only time they give a shit about us is when they need our dark skin for some ‘ethnic’ photo shoot and in this case with Ondria, they couldn't even be bothered. Can I see a black girl do SCANDANAVIAN PRINCESS please? Hmmm?”

More from Living: How to look slimmer — instantly!

This is not the first incident a magazine has caused a cultural stir.

In 2009, Vogue was accused of racism for using photos of white model, Lara Stone, with her face and body darkened in brown make-up.

Do you think it’s okay to use a white teen model in an "African Queen" spread?

Bing: Fashion advertising controversies

More from Simply Chic:
Ralph Lauren Hires First Plus-Size Model
What Would Barbie's Proportions Look Like on a Real Woman?
What makes women feel their sexiest?

Feb 26, 2013 11:50PM
NO, its when they do something like this, if she is African then why not show her true color!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Feb 26, 2013 11:50PM

First, this is not "Black Face" or racist in that sense. The fact that they "prefered" to use a white model is the problem I have.  As hard as it is for the average black person to get into fashion modelling (you can check the percentatges), this could have been a big break for some upcoming young African/Afro-American/Black woman model.


Second, it somewhat is like the 4 Oscar-nominated, "Beasts of the Southern Wild". Most movie chains did not want to show it. A PG-13 southern fantasy, was too BLACK?


It is important to profit, but it is just as important to be fair. If we work just to make ourselvesd a profit, we aren't helping anyone else.In most religions this "Golden Rule" and giving back way of life is important.


Just be FAIR and SHARE!


Peace [:>)}

Feb 26, 2013 11:50PM
What about black women drenching themselves "in White makeup, dying their hair blond, getting plastic surgery to straighten out their noses, implanting cheeks, reducing lips, hips and getting surgery to lose their African body shapes, starving themselves and wearing green and blue contact lenses, and secretly dating every white man on the planet, whether he is married or not!.

If a magazine does this and knows it is going to create a firestorm, they are smart....they get all the attention and sales for that issue.

Real issues like GMO's, poverty in America - while our elected officials shell out billions in foreign aid, women being murdered and raped all over the World and our youth tattooing themselves to death are not a concern.

Next, we will see white men, dressed as black women on the cover of every magazine and listen to all the women complain in unison!

Get over it, it is just an advertising scam! 

Feb 26, 2013 11:50PM
This is not a picture of a WHITE AFRICAN!!!!!
Feb 26, 2013 11:49PM
I agree.  The magazine should have tried to find a black model for this shoot.  There's just no good reason not to do that.
Feb 26, 2013 11:49PM
You people on here are absolute idiots. Yes there are White People who live in Africa now but they are from all over Europe, they landed in africa but they are not in my opion nor should they ever be considered African. There would never be a White African Queen because europeans do not originate from Africa so your post makes no sense. Black people have lived in america, died for this coutry and built it on the back of slavery yet we still get called African American instead of simply American , but yet you call a white person an African this is nonsense.  African Queen should be reserved for those who deserve that title not a european posing in bronzer it diminshes the true beauty of what Africans really look like and exhaults white people as the beauty standard. This nonsense has got to stop
Feb 26, 2013 11:49PM
Feb 26, 2013 11:49PM
I think it's pretty daring and cool. As a black person, I could choose to be annoyed and take it to heart. I'd rather not harp on such issues as race and color lines. I've had ENOUGH of that to deal with, living in America. Ondria looks fantabulous in "blackface", that is something I can handle.
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

beauty tips and style advice

  • Model

    Swimwear company apologies for drastic photoshopping of size 8 model

    "Unfortunately like most magazines, media and images you see on here, the girls have been retouched to look, taller, thinner ... all to see a product."

  • g1

    10 fall pieces you should be buying—and wearing—right now

    The redeeming factor of summer, sadly, not being endless? New seasons require a different wardrobe, and there’s no time like the present to start your fall shopping. With autumn creeping up, I already know the boots and sweaters I’ll be heaving out of the stuffed containers under my bed that I think of fondly as my second closet…but there’s always room for fresh blood. I quizzed Shopbop’s fashion director, Elle Strauss, for help with getting the best strategy in place. Herewith, the 10 pieces she suggests picking up now (plus chic ideas for how to start incorporating them into your current closet).

  • Denim upgrades

    18 denim downgrades that are total fashion upgrades

    These jeans aren't just distressed, they're destroyed, and all the cooler for it — the perfect way to make a basic T-shirt feel totally badass.

  • Courtesy of the Company // Courtesy of the Company

    10 drugstore beauty classics you should absolutely own

    These products are so great they’ve attained cult status among beauty insiders—yet you can find them just about anywhere without blowing your budget.

  • Courtesy of Retailers

    Your ultimate fall shoe guide!

    Those awesome back-to-school outfits are begging for some killer kicks! Strut down the hallway in fall's hottest shoe trends.

  • Getty Images // Magazine

    4 makeup tricks from celebs who look better than ever

    These stars don't sleep in a hyperbaric chamber (that we know of), yet they seem to look better with each passing year. That's because somewhere along the way, they discovered a few signature makeup tricks that make all the difference. Steal some of their game-changing moves.

  • Courtesy of the Company // Courtesy of the Company

    69 fall shoes under $100

    Your closet update just got way easier. Sneakers, heels, boots, flats—we've got it all covered.

  • Gap

    15 items that go from summer to fall effortlessly

    Dressing right gets tricky when summer turns to fall. It's too warm for tweed, but shorts just don't feel right anymore. Fortunately, Esquire's got it all figured out for you.

  • Jumpsuit, Getty Images

    5 things you should never wear on an airplane

    When you’re flying in a metal tube at 30,000 feet, comfort trumps style. To help you avoid an in-flight fashion faux pas, avoid wearing the 5 items below.

  • a1

    8 things you didn’t know about hair-smoothing treatments

    In the pursuit of silky, swingy, frizz-free hair, there are a dizzying number of tempting in-salon services to choose from. We grilled chemists and stylists on what works (and what’s safe). Here are the eight things you—and your hair—need to know before you commit.

  • 1

    5 beauty mistakes that can age mothers of the bride

    Beauty products have a lot of power. Applied expertly, they can make you look vibrant, gorgeous and at least five years younger. If you aren’t using them correctly, though, the same products can add a few years to your gorgeous visage. But before mothers of the bride go into panic mode, read on. We asked makeup artist Brigitte Reiss-Andersen, who’s worked with the likes of Meryl Streep, Michelle Pfeiffer and Rachel Weisz, to divulge common beauty mistakes that you can nip in the bud before your daughter’s wedding.

  • a1

    7 genius tricks for organizing your beauty products

    Some people apply makeup at a vanity that’s crying out to be on Pinterest, and others rummage through a drawer overflowing with their 103 absolute must-have, use-daily products—but everybody can benefit from a few clever storage tricks. These are the smartest ways we’ve ever heard to keep your products and tools organized, accessible, and most of all, beautiful.

follow us
follow us follow us on facebook follow us on pinterest follow us on twitter
buzzing now on msn living
about our blog contributors
style videos
editor's picks