The Heart Beat The Heart Beat blog

Why nice guys actually do finish last

Do women really want bad boys, or is dependability a more attractive trait?

By Kristin Wong Apr 30, 2013 5:17PM

As the loving girlfriend of a classic nice guy, I've never quite understood the complaint that they finish last. "Girls always want bad boys," my male friends often lament. "I feel like I should be a jerk just to get dates."

Photo: Guy helping girl up tree / Philip Lee Harvey/Getty Images Admittedly, the stats support their claim. A 2012 University of Texas study found that ovulating women view bad boys as better mating partners. In 2011, researchers from Notre Dame and Cornell found a link between "agreeableness" and low earnings for men. And a poll from that same year found that women do indeed have a thing for broody boys.

More on MSN Living: Funniest save the dates from Pinterest

So what's the deal? Why do some women fall for rebellious dudes and not their nice, dependable counterparts? 

Dating and relationship expert Lucia says there are two main reasons. She tells MSN Living’s The Heart Beat:

“Nice guys don't set boundaries. They let women get away with everything and agree with anything they say or want to do. Women don't respect men who behave like doormats and can't be attracted to men they don't respect.”
She adds, “Nice guys don’t appear to be as confident as ‘bad boys.’” Confidence is a crucial trait when it comes to attractiveness, Lucia says.
In an article for YourTango.com, she also says that being too nice can be counterproductive: “No one can always be that nice unless they're a saint. They are busy being nice instead of being real, and women instinctually don't trust that."

More on MSN Living: Funniest wedding invitations from Pinterest

Nice guys will argue that women simply crave excitement. Lucia doesn't disagree.

"Women are attracted to bad boys for a multitude of reasons, only one of which is challenge.  The type of women who are interested in the challenge are generally younger, have a low self-esteem and/or are afraid of intimacy and don't want a real relationship.”

But there's hope yet. Researchers Geoffrey Urbaniak and Peter Kilmann authored "Physical Attractiveness and the 'Nice Guy Paradox': Do Nice Guys Really Finish Last?" In that study, they found that kindness is the most important trait women seek when choosing a serious partner.

"Niceness appeared to be the most salient factor when it came to desirability for more serious relationships, whereas physical attractiveness appeared more important in terms of desirability for more casual, sexual relationships."

When it comes to dating, perhaps bad boys have the advantage, though this study seems to find it's more about looks than anything else. But when it comes to the long haul, women do indeed fall for kindness and agreeability.

Bing: This kind of man is more likely to cheat, study finds

“Everything in life is about balance,” Lucia says. “Guys who are too nice need to understand that the ideal man is neither a bad boy nor a nice guy but a combination of both.”

More from The Heart Beat:

Sex survey says women are better than men in bed
Airline plays matchmaker with passengers

Subscribe to The Heart Beat

Love content like this? Friend us on Facebook, follow us on Twitter and find us on Pinterest.

Photo: Philip Lee Harvey/Getty Images

May 13, 2013 7:49PM
This isn't very uplifting for the "nice guy".  To put it another way, when women are at their hottest, most care free, most interested in unencumbered relationships, they want the "bad boy".  However, once they are done with the casual sex thing, and they want to settle down and get into the emotional and financial support phase of relationships, they will turn to the "nice guy".  So after 5, 10, 30, failed relationship attempts, the girl finally settles for the "nice guy"?  And the "nice guy" gets the girl with the emotional baggage that the "bad boy" left sitting on the train platform?
May 4, 2013 4:08PM
It's amazing.  I've been reading the comments users have left.  So long as the comment misogynistic it's thumbs up and congratulatory all the way around.  Soon as individuals start commenting that men are exactly the same, the haters come out.
May 4, 2013 7:06AM
This is a stupid article. There is a difference between nice guys and doormats. You can be a nice guy but not be stupid or gullible or easily manipulated.
May 4, 2013 5:35AM
That's a lot of words to say "Women are dirty whores."
May 4, 2013 4:26AM
When I was younger I didn't act right or treat women as well as I do now, that was mostly from being young and immature. But on the other hand, I never had to try to get girls then, they fell over left and right even though I didn't really care for them. Too many women get caught up in the "bad boy" thing and then get their hearts broken and then bash men. Ladies make better decisions, the bad boy may seem fun, but he doesn't care about you.
May 4, 2013 4:24AM
I ran the nice guy track for years. No one stayed around very long.  I changed to love them and leave them. Even today at 83 it still works.  I got a girl pregnant and married her 57 year ago. Seven ex girl friends followed me around for years.  Where were they when I was a nice guy and treated my women as would be wifes with respect. Two still issue me invitation.  All Others of the seven  have passed on.  One of which has never married.   I just don't understand it even today.
May 4, 2013 4:06AM
My experience has been that most women really don't know what they want, or else they won't admit to what they want.  So a nice guy tries to give them what they say they want, but half the time that's not it.  And the bad boys just do whatever they please and just by sheer luck and chance quite often they hit the mark, no pun intended. 
May 4, 2013 3:52AM
I've been married for 30 years and I've treated my wife with respect and a lady.  We love each other.  Marriage isn't drama, it's reality.  Having common goals but not necessarily agreeing on everything, and give and take is what makes a relationship work.  I'll be honest with you it hasn't been easy, there are good times and bad.  Those are part of the vows you take most people do anyways.  One important thing I forgot to add, we believe in GOD we go to church every Sunday and we love our neighbor as ourselves.
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

love: friendships, dating, sex & marriage

  • The Viceroy Anguilla

    Great getaways for a spring-summer honeymoon

    As a general rule, any island that offers great weather year-round is going to attract the most visitors in the winter (high season) when we’re all trying to escape the snow. Once summer rolls around, many islands see a sharp drop-off in tourism since many people have beach weather right in their own backyards.

  • Getty Images

    The top 10 complaints from unhappy husbands

    And how you can attack the issues together.

  • 25 wedding photo bombs

    25 wedding photo bombs

    A wedding is an exceptionally special day. Sometimes, an opportune photo flub makes the occasion even more memorable. Here are 25 awesome wedding photo bombs.

  • He takes you on nondrinking dates.

    7 signs he’s getting serious about you

    Somewhere between the first few butterfly-inducing dates and the committed-for-life stage, there’s the period of wondering if you’re both on the same page about how serious you feel about a future together. If you’re not quite at the point of "that talk" but you’re looking for a few clues you’re heading in that direction, here are some signs he’s in it for the long haul as your relationship progresses.

  • 'Have you tried online dating?'

    15 things single people are tired of hearing

    What’s that sound? It’s white noise blocking out the well-meaning person proclaiming groundbreaking news about where you can meet someone, asking why you’re still single, or bugging you about when you’re getting married already. Don’t be that person. Here are 15 annoying things all single people don’t want to hear.

  • 1. New Hair Color

    11 things to avoid the week before your wedding

    With just a few days left before the big day, you already have a mile-long checklist of to-dos—now meet the don’ts! From impromptu skin treatments to all-night movie marathons, here are 11 things to avoid at all costs.

  • 'It’s a Wonderful Life'

    13 movie romances we can learn from

    A new study shows that watching and discussing romantic films can drastically reduce your chance of divorce. These flicks more than fit the bill.

  • About you and someone else

    10 things he’ll never forget you said

    These seemingly innocent phrases still have the power to wound… big time.

  • He or she is the first one you want to tell

    6 signs your marriage will last a lifetime

    Making "I do" last forever is one of the biggest challenges you'll ever face—and it's normal to worry about how you'll do it. But, if your connection involves any of these things, rest assured that you're in it for the long run.

  • Simone Becchetti, Getty Images // Simone Becchetti, Getty Images (Simone Becchetti, Getty Images)

    Can you stay together after a marital affair?

    Ultimately, as hard as it may seem at the beginning, a marital affair can be a turning point.

  • Biltmore/"Dream Wedding Recap"/Allan Zepeda/The Knot

    The Knot Dream Wedding recap

    Five months after the Boston Marathon bombing, The Knot reached out to Rebekah Gregory and Pete DiMartino and offered to throw them a dream wedding. They said yes, and on April 4, 2014, the two married at the Biltmore Estate in Asheville, North Carolina. Rebekah and Pete exchanged vows on the tennis lawn amidst the cherry tree blossoms and then celebrated with all of their friends and family at a beautiful reception tent right in front of the estate. All of the details were perfectly executed by a team of talented and generous wedding industry pros, including celebrity wedding planner Marcy Blum. Here, a few highlights from Rebekah and Pete's wedding day.

  • The dress code was too strict

    Top wedding guest complaints (and how to avoid them)

    Your wedding is your special day, but you want to keep your guests happy, too. Here are 20 typical wedding guest complaints and what you can do about them.

buzzing now on msn living
The Heart Beat is a Great Dating Blogs Winner The Heart Beat is a Great Dating Blogs Winner
relationship videos
editor's picks
the heart beat