The Daily Dose Blog The Daily Dose Blog Home

Airport Security: Too Much or Too Little?

Another TSA bombshell blows up a controversy

By Rich_Maloof Jun 5, 2012 4:54PM

Photo: Pablo Martinez Monsivais/APWhat do you see as the bigger problem in air travel today: lapses in airport security that increase your vulnerability to a terrorist act — or waiting on a long line, tossing out your 8-oz bottle of hair conditioner, and being subject to a full-body scan? Better decide, because you can’t have it both ways.

To date, striking a balance between tight security and the protection of civil liberties has been a major headache for the Office of Homeland Security, for politicians, and for the Transportation Security Administration (TSA) — not to mention for travelers.

The TSA seems to be forever under the gun, so to speak. When slack controls compromise safety, like when an ex-con slipped past security as a stowaway a few days ago, the federal agency is lambasted for incompetency. And when safety screenings require ticket-holders to sacrifice privacy (and lots of time) by removing shoes, opening luggage for inspection, and being patted down, travelers cry foul.

Not for the first time, the TSA is getting squeezed this week after serious lapses in security uncovered at Southwest Florida International Airport led to the firing and/or suspension of dozens of employees. It’s bad news for the agency at a time when its union is bucking for a labor contract to secure the group’s bargaining rights, which some members of congress support. But moreover it stokes the controversy over what constitutes too little or too much airport security.

There’s no shortage of voices on the issue, and you’ve probably heard some of them either thanking an airport agent or grumbling all the way through the security line. Some welcome any system that improves air-travel safety. Some want the TSA overhauled, and some want it hauled out altogether, like Florida Representative John Mica, who has politicized the issue: Mica champions the idea of taking the “bloated bureaucracy” of airport security out of the government’s control and privatizing it.

Then there are voices such as the one belonging to Al Maurer of the Washington Times, who characterizes the TSA system as “invasive and time-consuming” and calls agents “scanner nazis.” Maurer even likens a TSA agent’s following of instructions to the Nuremberg defense of a guard at a Nazi concentration camp. Taking his horrific analogy to a quantifiably insane degree, Maurer goes on to compare the complicity of the American public in airport screenings to the complicity of Germans in the atrocities committed by the SS. If there’s any atrocity here, it’s Maurer’s obscene abuse of free speech.

But we digress.

Should civil liberties trump security, or vice versa? Are travelers getting the protection they need when the TSA yanks stun guns, knives, and pistols off the guy in seat 12C, or is a lackluster agent just as likely to miss his pal in 14B? Here at the cusp of the busy summer travel season, when you or someone you care about is likely to board an airplane, it’s worth a thought.

Aug 7, 2012 7:23PM
Do sheep and cattle thank the people who guide them to slaughter?
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

inspire: live a better life

  • 13 ways to improve your life this spring

    13 ways to improve your life this spring

    No one looks forward to washing windows or storing the ski gear or the other chores associated with spring-cleaning. But this annual ritual does not have to be a drag, if you approach it in a slightly different way. "You've been cooped up with this cave-like mentality all winter; now it's time to break free and play," says R.D. Chin, a feng shui architect and consultant in New York City. "It's time to follow the cycle of nature, get rid of the clutter, and free up your mind." Here's our idea of what a truly effective spring-cleaning can look like.

  •  David Paul Morris, Bloomberg via Getty Images //  David Paul Morris, Bloomberg via Getty Images ( David Paul Morris, Bloomberg via Getty Images)

    Top Americans of all time named

    American presidents garner most votes over celebrities in a poll ranking the 100 most significant citizens.

  • The 10 coldest travel destinations on Earth

    The 10 coldest travel destinations on Earth

    Heading to a world-class beach town is always a safe bet for a great vacation, but if you want something that tests your limits, consider a more extreme spot. Here are 10 places around the world that require a winter coat year-round and offer spectacular glaciers, ice features, and the best snow anywhere.

  • 50 hidden gems in the US

    51 hidden gems in the US

    From the Grand Canyon to the Statue of Liberty, the U.S. boasts world-famous national parks, historical sites and landmarks. Beyond the well-known locations, there's a wealth of undiscovered destinations stretching from coast to coast worth visiting. From scenic sand dunes to wild mountains, here's 51 places within America that you've probably never heard of.

  • Hudson Bay has old earth rocks

    10 interesting facts about the Earth

    How much do you really know about the Earth? In honor of Earth Day, April 22, we explore some interesting and fun facts about the fifth-largest planet of our solar system.

  • stress and happiness

    Beat stress and boost happiness

    Most of the stuff we worry about never happens.

  • How to end an email

    You've written an email, and need to wrap it up. You could end with a simple "Sincerely," tack on your name, and then shoot it out the door, proving definitively that you suck at communication.

  • Go where few have gone

    Craziest places to visit on the planet

    Here are nine of the most extreme trips on the planet -- and the outfitters that take adventurers over the edge and back again.

  • 10 serious adventures anyone can conquer

    10 serious adventures anyone can conquer

    A true challenge is within your reach. All it takes is a few months to get in shape and a few days off work.

  • How to set a world record

    How to set a world record

    Think you got what it takes to be included in the pages of the Guinness Book of World Records? We consult one of the judges to help you on your quest.

  • User-friendly home automation

    8 ways to smarten up your home

    Just a few years ago, the term "home automation" meant a bunch of blinking lights and a headache. But thanks to simpler interfaces and the rise of smartphones, new tech can transform your house into a safer, more comfortable, less wasteful place.

  • The 13 most annoying people on the airplane

    The 13 most annoying people on the airplane

    If you're like most people, flying around in a big metal tube in the sky isn't your idea of a fun time. From the terrible food to the cramped space, flying can be a miserable experience. Don't make the flight even more soul-sucking by breaking airplane etiquette. We've compiled a list of the worst-inflight offenders. by Rebecca Pattee

about rich maloof
buzzing now on msn living
inspire videos
editor's picks