The Daily Dose Blog The Daily Dose Blog Home

The Limits of Loyalty

By Rich_Maloof Jul 13, 2012 3:52PM

Nothing deserves attention in the Sandusky case as much as the bravery of the victims who have come forward, the horrors of a trusted authority figure, and the damning of every person responsible for concealing the truth. But one thread running through the many layers of this heinous case is the issue of loyalty. Was the seemingly admirable trait of loyalty, whether to a friend or to a venerated institution, behind the refusal of Paterno and others to blow the whistle on Sandusky?

The philosopher Simon Keller, in his award-winning book The Limits of Loyalty, begins to define loyalty as “the idea of a certain kind of relationship between individuals and the things to which they are loyal.” Though loyalty has the potential to be an admirable trait, it’s not in an of itself a virtue. It can be woven into a relationship with no acknowledgment at all of moral code. Think of what loyalty, whether blind or with eyes wide open, to certain people and causes has wrought over the course of history. Loyalty can be harnessed for good just as easily as it can be exploited for evil.

Loyalty to a legacy has now surfaced as a problem for Penn State alums and fans. Should the famous statue of Paterno remain standing in loyalty to the winningest coach in major-college football history? While the university decides, a guard is now posted to protect the sculpture. Comments on a NYT blog cover the range of responses: “That Paterno statue needs to come down Baghad-style today!”; “I'm numb to the lack of patience…Tear down a statue based on 61 years of service, the majority before the stain of one man arose?”; “Keep the statue, but turn it around 180 degrees because Paterno looked the other way.”

There’s no inherent value in loyalty without integrity. No virtue at all can be wrung out of the complicity of Joe Paterno and other Penn State officials in the Sandusky affair. Loyalty is justifiably smashed under the weight of moral corruption. Sandusky abdicated all loyalty with his atrocities. Paterno, Spanier, Shultz, Curley — none of them owed him a damn thing, and they should have known as much.

Photo: Paul Vathis/AP


inspire: live a better life

about rich maloof
buzzing now on msn living
inspire videos
editor's picks